Home  Resources  References  Tubes  Forums  Links  Support 
Transistor subs. for tubes
12/4/2006 4:48:07 PMRandy
Has anyone created a list or site for transistors or circuits to replace tubes?
12/4/2006 5:49:31 PMGreg Bilodeau
Just wondering, why would you want to do that when most tubes are easy to come by?

:Has anyone created a list or site for transistors or circuits to replace tubes?

12/4/2006 6:14:37 PMDoug Criner
Rectifier tubes can be replaced with diodes or plug-in units available from AES www.tubesandmore.com Would need to deal with higher B+ and possibly coming up too fast, though?

But I think most amplifier and detector tubes would take dozens of transistors and passive components to make up a one-to-one replacement that could be plugged into a tube socket. To start with, a tube's plate and grid voltages are way off from what typical solid-state circuits need to see, biasing is different, and performance is quite different.

If I were going to try, my first choice would be to use an A-D converter on the tube's grid input, send the digitized signal to a microprocessor programmed to simulate the tube's performance, and then a D-A for the output. Also, need a regulated power supply that perhaps could be derived from the filament ckt? Not sure how to interface the output to the plate ckt.

I'm not aware of a "list or site" on this subject.


:Just wondering, why would you want to do that when most tubes are easy to come by?
:
::Has anyone created a list or site for transistors or circuits to replace tubes?

12/4/2006 7:29:27 PMRandy
The real old tubes are getting super hard to find and even though some claim to be NOS I have had some bad ones. Even some that have tested good on my testers are no good when in the set.
12/4/2006 8:02:26 PMDoug Criner
Randy, please tell us the specific tube types you are looking for.

:The real old tubes are getting super hard to find and even though some claim to be NOS I have had some bad ones. Even some that have tested good on my testers are no good when in the set.

12/4/2006 8:12:35 PMDoug Criner
Usually it's the other way around. A tube will test "?" on a tube tester, but work fine in a radio.

:The real old tubes are getting super hard to find and even though some claim to be NOS I have had some bad ones. Even some that have tested good on my testers are no good when in the set.



© 1989-2025, Nostalgia Air